The Silence

1998 [PERSIAN]

Action / Drama / Music

Plot summary


Uploaded by: FREEMAN

Top cast

720p.BLU 1080p.BLU
634.66 MB
1280*682
Persian 2.0
NR
23.976 fps
1 hr 16 min
P/S ...
1.2 GB
1920*1024
Persian 2.0
NR
23.976 fps
1 hr 16 min
P/S ...

Movie Reviews

Reviewed by JuguAbraham8 / 10

The best work of Mohsen Makhmalbaf

Hearing music with a camera. The best Mohsen Makhmalbaf film yet for me. He is a director who can create magic with sound for a film. We glimpsed this in "Gabbeh", made 2 years earlier. Forget the narrative, it is the magical skill of combining music with innocently beautiful visuals here. A young blind tuner of musical instruments turns composer. The film is a tribute to Beethoven's "Fifth Symphony."

The attempt to bring in animal sounds into the music was accomplished well. The mural behind the kids at the bus stop is clearly indicative of the fact that the film was shot in Tajikistan and not in Iran

Reviewed by Andy-2968 / 10

Beautiful, poetic film set in Tajikistan

I saw this film when it was released, more than a decade ago, and I haven't seen it since. So I don't recall all the details. Directed by the famous Iranian filmmaker Mohsen Makhmalbaf, the movie is set in the little known republic of Tajikistan. A former Soviet republic in Central Asia, Tajikistan became independent in 1991 and suffered greatly from poverty and civil war in the first years of independence (in one moving scene in the film, an elderly Russian resident of Tajikistan laments, to the point of almost crying, his economic troubles). The Tajiks are ethnically very close to the Iranians; some say that the Tajik language is just a dialect of Farsi. As shown in the film, Tajikistan seems almost frozen in time, while the movie is set in the late 1990s, a lot of the buildings and cars seem to belong to perhaps the 1950s or 1960s, the floor of most of the houses seems to be made of earth, and the factory where part of the action takes place has an abacus and an old telephone line, but not a computer (I hope that in the time since this film was made, Tajikistan has modernized a bit). The busy bazaars and narrow alleys add to the feeling of a strange place to a western viewer.

The protagonist is a blind 10 year old boy, who relates to the world through sounds (the first chords of Beethoven's fifth symphony are a motif throughout the film). Coming from a very poor family, he works in a dilapidated factory tuning the instruments made there (I suppose being blind makes him more able to concentrate on the sounds). A beautiful little girl, who wears tresses and dresses in traditional multicolored Tajik clothes, seems to be his only friend. There is not much else in the movie in terms of action, I suppose that to appreciate this film you just have to sit back and enjoy what you are seeing. The amazingly beautiful color photography certainly helps. It is a poetic movie, but in a good way, unlike in other art movies, this film never feels forced or pretentious.

Reviewed by ridi-arahan7 / 10

A musical tribute to a legendary composer

What worked:

  • the theme of the movie; the general theme of the movie is appealing and strong. The movie helps gain more insight into a new society that I did not know much about. What works is the innocence that the blind character portrays in the movie
What did not know:
  • acting; the acting is not convincing and relatable. Maybe the movie has its cultural significance, it failed to impress as a world viewer
  • screenplay; although the overall concept is good, the movie does not carry that concept into a strong narrative
Final verdict: if you want to see something different, go for it

Read more IMDb reviews