Trying to tell a Hanukkah story in the (Hallmark) Christmas movie format is likely to get mixed reactions. Yet, for the past few years, this is what Hallmark has done, and the last two have been delightful. Though arguably not as good as last year's 'Love, Lights, Hanukkah!', the 'Eight Gifts of Hanukkah' is a lovely romance nonetheless with some strong acting to boot. The story revolves around Sarah (played by Inbar Lavi),who is back on the dating scene a few months after a difficult breakup. On each night of Hanukkah, she receives a gift from an anonymous suitor. Meanwhile, her childhood best friend, the boy-next-door, Daniel (played by Jake Epstein),secretly pines for her. So, our story begins as we watch Sarah solve the mystery of her secret admirer, eventually learning that true love might be someone you least expect. Although the story is predictable, as is the case with most Hallmark movies, it is engaging and compelling nonetheless. In particular, the writers do a wonderful job of developing the mystery and backstories around the eight gifts. Indeed, this is one of the most appealing elements of the story. The family dialogue, interactions, and dynamics are also beautifully done. These scenes feel real, giving the story an air of authenticity. What makes this all work on-screen, of course, is the acting, which is excellent. Lavi's performance is notable. She does a brilliant job of portraying Sarah's growing attraction for Daniel (and how she is confused by it) as the story progresses. Epstein's performance is also very strong, convincing. There is no doubt how Daniel feels about Sarah. Moreover, the two have great chemistry on-screen. The closeness and friendship they portray feel real. The closeness of the family, in general, is one of the appealing elements of the movie. The family interactions and dynamics are well done. David Kaye's performance as Jacob (Sarah's brother) is excellent, for example. I also enjoyed the Hanukkah storyline in this one. You have, of course, the typical Hanukkah celebration items such as menorahs, dreidels, brisket, and kugel. There is a beautiful hand-made dreidel that Daniel gives Sarah. The movie also depicts the Festival of Lights through several events such as family dinners, a Hanukkah Hunt, a menorah lighting at the Jewish Community Center, and the Mazel Ball. Indeed, the movie spends a significant amount of time presenting the celebration of Hanukkah and Jewish culture. All in all, 'Eight Gifts of Hanukkah' is a lovely holiday romance, a nice edition to Hallmark's Christmas movie line-up this season. I highly recommend it.

I came into this movie late then restarted it after seeing the chemistry between Inbar Lavi and Jake Epstein. Their friendship felt real as did the closeness of the family. The casting in this movie was very good.

I also enjoyed the Hanukkah storyline(not jewish but have friends who celebrate the same way) and the mystery of the gifts.

Yes, it was obvious from the beginning it was Daniel but the real mystery for me was the personal meaning behind each gift and what he would give her on the eight night so the ending was a complete surprise which is hard to come by in a Hallmark movie.

6/10 - Hallmark's first unabashedly Hanukkah-focused movie (that Double Holiday movie that focuses more on Christmas does not count) is a really pretty sweet romance that perfectly follows the Hallmark formula.